Title:
City of Lost Souls
Author:
Cassandra Clare
Publish Date: May 8, 2012, Simon and Schuster
Synopsis:
Can the lost be reclaimed? What price is too high to pay for love? Who can be trusted when sin and salvation collide?
Love. Blood. Betrayal. Revenge.
Darkness threatens to claim the Shadowhunters in the harrowing fifth book of the Mortal Instruments series.
This is such a hard review for me to write because I’m such a huge fan of Cassie’s and I love every one of her books. I really do. It bothered me to read some of the more critical reviews of
City of Fallen Angels. I know it hurt to watch our beloved characters have to go through even more trials and pain, but aren’t those the very best stories in the end? Well,
City of Lost Souls, is such a perfectly written story that I think even the strongest critics will have to agree with me.
You see, Cassie turns up the comedy in such a truly funny way that I found myself literally laughing out loud (not just “HA-ing” or giggling). The sarcasm and gentle jabs between the characters are so sweet and exactly what I’ve grown to expect from them. Here’s an example featuring Isabelle and Simon (from chapter 7: A Sea Change):
“Can you tell me a story?”
He blinked. “What kind of story?”
“Something where the good guys win and the bad guys lose. And stay dead.”
“So, like a fairy tale?” he asked. He racked his brain. He knew only the Disney versions of fairy tales and the first image that came to mind was Ariel in her seashell bra. He’d had a crush on her when he was eight. Not that this seemed like the time to mention it.
“No.” The word was an exhaled breath. “We study fairy tales in school. A lot of that magic is real—but, anyway. No, I want something I haven’t heard yet.”
“Okay, I’ve got a good one,” Simon stroked Isabelle’s hair, feeling her lashes flutter against his neck as she closed her eyes. “A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away…”
See what I mean? And then, Cassie gives us these lovely scenes that make our hearts ache as we realize that all of the characters have matured and the world is a much more complicated place for them. There’s a bittersweet moment with just about every one of the pairings. And I won’t even mention my favorite scene in Venice on a boat…
As if all that isn’t enough, Cassie blurs the lines between Team Bad and Team Good. Oh yeah, she does it and does it well. You will be swayed by the baddest of baddies. For those who hate a cliffhanger ending, oh just you wait…you get my favorite kind of ending, a soft landing before the inevitable has to happen in the next book. I have nothing else to add except – this, THIS is exactly how a series should be written.
Our Over All Rating:


First let me just say I totally agree with Sophie's comments above. But I wanted to add a little bit more and talk about the audiobok.
Cassandra Clare has stepped it up with both her writing and her story telling in City of Lost Souls. The story is emotional, full of detail (SOOO many clues! I'm now DYING for Clockwork Princess and City of Heavenly Fire), and ties together all three series (Infernal Devices, The Mortal Instruments and The Dark Artifices) in amazing Cassie fashion. And even though this is the middle book in the second trilogy, it doesn't have that middle book feel. It totally could stand on its own and propels the story forward.
City of Lost Souls picks up right where City of Fallen Angels ends. Clary, Izzy, Simon, Alec and the whole gang are working to figure out whats going on with Jace and how they can set everything right. Clary is also dealing with the fallout of what happened with Jace and the Angel at the lake. (Yeah I'm trying to be as spoiler free as possible for the rest of the series.) It was a blast reading how Cassie was able to bring everything together in such a way that didn't feel like a cop-out and felt true to the story. I also enjoyed getting more Magnus. He's an amazing character who spans the two existing series with a beautiful story line that I'm DYING to know how it all plays out.
I have actually not "read" a single Cassandra Clare novel, I've listened to them all on audiobook. Molly Quinn is back for another Cassandra Clare audio and she continues her streak as an amazing narrator. Only thing missing was having Ed Westwick back reading the male character parts, but that's just a little personal preference hehe (LOVE Ed's reading voice). But Molly does a great job of bringing life to each character and doesn't over play the voices. The audio had me feeling like I'm a kid again having someone read me a story, which I think, is the best compliment for any audiobook and narrator.
If you're considering a re-read of Cassandra Clare's books, try them on audio. All seven books are amazingly well done and I think you'll pick up on some details and ideas that you might not have picked up on while reading the story.